Arc of Prosperity

Scottish Independence within the EU – with a Scandinavian Slant


It’s a small step, but at least it’s a step forward

travel step photoI must admit I was a bit sceptical before Nicola Sturgeon’s most recent announcement whether she’d say anything concrete.

And to be honest, there are so many caveats in it that it’s not clear it changes much. There’ll be a referendum before 2021 if the UK has left the EU – but presumably not if Brexit has been cancelled or delayed further, or if the deal gets signed and the country enters transition. It’s also not clear what exactly she’ll do if Westminster refuses to play ball when she asks them to approvement the referendum (as I’m sure they will). That doesn’t mean she hasn’t got a plan, of course, but the rest of us are none the wiser.

So I have to agree with other commentators that it was probably the smallest possible step she could take while keeping the Yes movement on board, but at least she took it.

Also, she’s put the SNP on a campaign footing. I’ve been girning for years that she was watching the polls but not doing anything to make them move, so I’m absolutely delighted with that bit. It also makes it much harder to march the troops down the hill again – gauging from social media reactions, I’m not sure many of them really noticed the caveats, and I doubt they won’t be very happy if she stops the campaign again later.

So all in all, it was a welcome step, albeit a small one. Hopefully the campaign that is starting now will shift public opinion in Scotland and create a demand for a new referendum that the Unionist parties will find it hard to resist.

One thought on “It’s a small step, but at least it’s a step forward

  • Good to see you posting again.

    I think Nicola will ask Westminster for a S30 order, as that is the Gold Standard, as she put it. A S30 is not in any way permission to hold a referendum, but rather an agreement that Westminster will abide by the outcome. Well who cares if they do or not, they are not the arbiters, the people of Scotland are and if this goes to an international court Westminster will lose. The Claim of Right was agreed by Westminster in 2018, they have no leg to stand on. As we say “its game on”. In the end realpolitik will win out and a negotiation will follow.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *